When an endpoint is a letter, the answer is an expression
Sometimes one end of the interval is a letter, like [0, a] or [5, a]. You follow exactly the same steps, but the letter stays a letter, so the answer is an expression such as a + 7 instead of a single number. That expression is a reusable shortcut: put in any allowed endpoint for a and it gives the average rate of change, with no new work. Think of a taxi fare formula: once you have it, you can price different trip lengths. Here you are building the rate formula rather than the fare formula. Factoring means rewriting a sum as multiplication; that can reveal a whole factor to cancel.
- Sum-and-product factoring. (a + p)(a + q) = + (p + q)a + pq. For + 2a − 35, choose p = 7 and q = −5.
- Difference of squares. − 4 = (b − 2)(b + 2), since the +2b and −2b terms cancel when multiplied out.
- Solving a one-step equation. In b + 3 = 11, subtract 3 from both sides to get b = 8, then substitute 8 back into the equation.
- Canceling a common factor. = a + 3 requires a ≠ 0. Canceling reverses multiplication, not addition.
Say 'the endpoint is a number I have not chosen yet'.
The average rate can be an expression in the endpoint letter; choosing an endpoint then gives a numerical rate.
- , a ≠ 0
- , a ≠ 5
- [5, a] for a > 5; [a, 5] for a < 5
A reusable taxi price formula works for many trip lengths; a reusable rate formula works for many endpoints.
For f(x) = + 2x − 8, start at 5. Read the drawn columns as input endpoint above average rate. At a = 7, the column gives 14 because = 14. Each column follows the expression a + 7; the worked algebra below explains why the same shortcut serves every allowed endpoint.
A taxi price card accepts a chosen trip length. In the same way, the rate expression a + 7 accepts a chosen endpoint. Choosing a = 6 gives 13; choosing a = 8 gives 15. The endpoint letter names a number, rather than an instruction to solve yet.
The product (a + 7)(a − 5) gives + 2a − 35 when multiplied out. This makes the matching whole factor a − 5 visible. Canceling then means dividing that factor by itself, which gives 1 when it is nonzero.
.1A letter becomes a number when you choose it
A letter endpoint allows many numerical intervals to be described at once. A rate table can show the pattern before you rebuild it algebraically.
- For f(x) = + 2x − 8 starting at 5, rate = a + 7.
- x, t, a, and b are names; their role is determined by the formula and the question.
This asks for one numerical average before rebuilding all endpoints at once. Take a = 7 in f(x) = + 2x − 8 on [5, a].
- The endpoint interval becomes [5, 7], with f(5) = 25 + 10 − 8 = 27 and f(7) = 49 + 14 − 8 = 55.Choosing a = 7 gives a numerical value to the endpoint letter.
- = = 14.The ordinary endpoint formula still applies; the rate table highlights this result under input 7.
.2A three-term numerator needs a factoring puzzle
After evaluating and subtracting, + 2a − 35 needs two factors. Find numbers that multiply to −35 and add to 2. Check the product before canceling.
- 7 · (−5) = −35 and 7 + (−5) = 2.
- (a + 7)(a − 5) = + 2a − 35.
- The original rate excludes a = 5.
Let f(x) = − 4x + 1, which can also be written f(x) = (x − 2 − 3. Consider the interval [5, a], where a > 5.
(1) Write the average rate of change of f on [5, a] as a simplified expression in a.
(2) Find the value of a for which the average rate of change on [5, a] equals 9.
- Evaluate the fixed endpoint: f(5) = − 4(5) + 1 = 25 − 20 + 1 = 6.The input 5 is a number, so its output is a number. It is one of the two outputs in the difference quotient.
- Substitute the letter: f(a) = − 4a + 1.The other endpoint is the letter a. Replacing x with a gives the second output as an expression.
- Write the quotient: rate = = = , with a ≠ 5.Average rate of change is the change in output over the change in input. Both differences take the same order: a first, then 5. The denominator cannot be zero, so a ≠ 5. This also follows from the condition a > 5.
- Factor the numerator: − 4a − 5 = (a − 5)(a + 1). Check by multiplying back: (a − 5)(a + 1) = + a − 5a − 5 = − 4a − 5. ✓Two numbers that multiply to −5 and add to −4 are −5 and +1. Multiplying back confirms the factorization before anything is canceled.
- Cancel the common factor: = a + 1, for a ≠ 5.The factor (a − 5) multiplies the whole numerator, so it may be canceled. The restriction a ≠ 5 comes from the original quotient and stays in place.
- Set the rate equal to 9 and solve: a + 1 = 9, so a = 8.The simplified expression gives the rate for every allowed a. Setting it equal to the given rate leaves a linear equation.
- Check the endpoint. The value a = 8 satisfies a > 5 and a ≠ 5. In the original quotient, f(8) = 64 − 32 + 1 = 33, and = = 9. ✓Any solution must be checked against the original restrictions and the original unsimplified quotient, not only the simplified expression.
Work to write
- f(5) = 6
- f(a) = − 4a + 1
- rate = , a ≠ 5
- − 4a − 5 = (a − 5)(a + 1)
- rate = a + 1, a ≠ 5
- a + 1 = 9 ⇒ a = 8
- Check: = 9 ✓
(1) The average rate of change on [5, a] is a + 1, for a ≠ 5 (here a > 5). (2) a = 8, so the interval is [5, 8].
.3Working backward from a given rate
Evaluate means an input is given and you find the output. Solve means a target is given and you find the input that produces it. First build the rate expression, then solve for the endpoint that gives the target rate.
- A target rate produces an equation for the endpoint.
- Check the candidate in the original quotient, not only the shortened expression.
- A canceled denominator still leaves an excluded input.
Let f(x) = + 2x − 6, which can also be written f(x) = (x + 1 − 7. Consider the interval whose endpoints are 5 and a, where a ≠ 5.
(1) Write the average rate of change of f between 5 and a as a simplified expression in a.
(2) Find the value of a for which this average rate of change equals 4. Write the interval in sorted order and check your answer in the original quotient.
- f(5) = + 2(5) − 6 = 25 + 10 − 6 = 29The fixed numerical endpoint is evaluated first, so one output is a plain number.
- f(a) = + 2a − 6Substituting the letter a for x gives the other output as an expression. It is defined for every real a.
- rate = = = , with a ≠ 5Average rate of change is the change in output over the matching change in input. Both differences take the same order, a first and 5 second. The denominator cannot be zero, so a ≠ 5.
- Factor: + 2a − 35 = (a − 5)(a + 7). Multiply back to verify: (a − 5)(a + 7) = + 7a − 5a − 35 = + 2a − 35 ✓We need two numbers with product −35 and sum 2. These are 7 and −5. Multiplying back confirms the factoring.
- rate = = a + 7, for a ≠ 5(a − 5) multiplies the whole numerator, so it can be canceled with the denominator. The restriction a ≠ 5 comes from the original quotient and is kept.
- Set a + 7 = 4, so a = −3.The rate is given as 4, so set the simplified expression equal to 4 and solve. The result a = −3 satisfies a ≠ 5.
- Since −3 < 5, the sorted interval is [−3, 5].When the letter endpoint is less than 5, the interval is written from smaller to larger. The quotient gives the same value in either order.
- Check in the original quotient: f(−3) = 9 − 6 − 6 = −3, so = = = 4 ✓Checking the endpoint in the unsimplified quotient confirms that the cancellation and the solving are correct.
Work to write
- f(5) = 29
- rate = = , a ≠ 5
- + 2a − 35 = (a − 5)(a + 7)
- rate = a + 7, a ≠ 5
- a + 7 = 4 ⇒ a = −3
- interval [−3, 5]
- check: = = 4
(1) The average rate of change is a + 7, for a ≠ 5. (2) a = −3, so the interval is [−3, 5].
.4Working backward when the rate contains a fraction
First combine the function outputs into one fraction. Dividing by the input difference can cancel a whole factor, leaving a rate equation you solve by doing the same multiplication to both sides.
- For g(x) = starting at 3, rate = , with b ≠ 0 and b ≠ 3.
- Target rate −1 gives b = 4.
This asks for an endpoint giving a specified average rate. Let g(x) = . Starting at 3, find b > 3 so the average rate on [3, b] is −1.
- Require b ≠ 0 for g(b), and b ≠ 3 for the input change. g(3) = = 4; g(b) = .Both the function output and the rate quotient need nonzero bottoms.
- g(b) − g(3) = − 4 = − = .Write the whole number 4 over bottom b by multiplying it by = 1.
- 12 − 4b = −4(b − 3).Multiplying −4 through the parentheses gives −4b + 12, the same numerator.
- The rate is ÷ (b − 3) = · = .Dividing by b − 3 means multiplying by its reciprocal; the factor cancels only because b ≠ 3.
- Set = −1, then multiply both sides by b: −4 = −b.This finds the input that gives rate −1; multiplying by b is allowed because b ≠ 0.
- Multiply both sides by −1: b = 4.The same multiplication preserves the equality and makes b positive.
- 4 > 3, 4 ≠ 0, and 4 ≠ 3.The candidate satisfies the requested interval and both original restrictions.
- Evaluate the fixed numerical endpoint.
- Substitute the endpoint letter to write the other output.
- Subtract the outputs and write the matching input difference.
- For a polynomial, factor the numerator and verify by multiplying back.
- Cancel only a matching factor multiplying the whole numerator, preserving the original restrictions.
- If the rate is given, set the simplified rate expression equal to that number, solve, and check the endpoint in the original quotient.
A letter endpoint, forward or backward
- Build the endpoint quotient before simplifying.
- Record all excluded inputs from function bottoms and the input difference.
- Use common factors, a difference of squares, or the sum-and-product factor puzzle when applicable.
- If requested, solve the rate equation and check the candidate in the original quotient.
Let f(x) = − 2x − 2. (a) Write the average rate of change of f between the inputs 5 and a, where a ≠ 5, as a simplified expression in a. (b) The average rate of change of f between 5 and a equals 7. Find a and state the interval.
- f(5) = − 2(5) − 2 = 25 − 10 − 2 = 13.The fixed numerical endpoint gives a number, so evaluate it first.
- f(a) = − 2a − 2.Replace every x with the endpoint letter a to get the other output.
- rate = = = , with a ≠ 5.The average rate is the change in output over the matching change in input, in the same order. a = 5 would make the denominator zero.
- − 2a − 15 = (a − 5)(a + 3). Check: (a − 5)(a + 3) = + 3a − 5a − 15 = − 2a − 15.Factor the polynomial numerator so that any factor matching the denominator becomes visible. Multiplying back confirms the factoring.
- rate = = a + 3, for a ≠ 5.(a − 5) multiplies the whole numerator and equals the denominator, so it cancels. The restriction a ≠ 5 from the original quotient still holds.
- Set a + 3 = 7, so a = 4.The given rate equals the simplified expression, so solve that equation for the endpoint.
- Check a = 4 in the original quotient: f(4) = 16 − 8 − 2 = 6, and = = 7. Since 4 < 5, the sorted interval is [4, 5].The endpoint must satisfy a ≠ 5 and give the stated rate in the unsimplified quotient. An interval is written with its smaller endpoint first.
Work to write
- f(5) = 13
- f(a) = − 2a − 2
- , a ≠ 5
- − 2a − 15 = (a − 5)(a + 3)
- rate = a + 3, a ≠ 5
- a + 3 = 7 ⇒ a = 4
- Check: = 7; interval [4, 5]
(a) The rate is a + 3, for a ≠ 5. (b) a = 4, and the interval is [4, 5].
This asks for the average rate from a fixed input to any different input b. Find it for f(x) = 4x + 9, starting at −2.
- f(−2) = 4(−2) + 9 = −8 + 9 = 1; f(b) = 4b + 9.The first output is numerical; the second keeps the endpoint letter.
- Output change: f(b) − f(−2) = (4b + 9) − 1 = 4b + 8.Subtract the entire starting output.
- Input change: b − (−2) = b + 2.The input change follows the same endpoint order.
- 4b + 8 = 4(b + 2), so = 4, with b ≠ −2.The factor b + 2 multiplies the whole top. The original bottom excludes b = −2.
Let f(x) = − 3x − 10. (a) Write the average rate of change of f from x = 5 to x = a, where a ≠ 5, as a simplified expression in a. (b) The average rate of change on [5, a] is 9. Find a.
- f(5) = − 3(5) − 10 = 25 − 15 − 10 = 0.The fixed numerical endpoint is evaluated first. Its output is 0, so subtracting it will not change the numerator.
- f(a) = − 3a − 10.Replacing x with the endpoint letter a gives the other output.
- Rate = = = , with a ≠ 5.Average rate of change is the change in output divided by the matching change in input, taken in the same order. The denominator cannot be 0.
- Factor the numerator: − 3a − 10 = (a − 5)(a + 2). Check by multiplying back: (a − 5)(a + 2) = + 2a − 5a − 10 = − 3a − 10.We need two numbers with product −10 and sum −3. Those are −5 and 2. Multiplying back confirms the factoring.
- Rate = = a + 2, for a ≠ 5.(a − 5) multiplies the whole numerator and matches the denominator, so it cancels. The restriction a ≠ 5 from the original quotient still applies.
- Set a + 2 = 9, so a = 7. Since 7 > 5, the interval is [5, 7].The given rate equals the simplified expression. The solution a = 7 is not 5, so it is allowed, and it gives the sorted interval [5, a].
- Check in the original quotient: f(7) = 49 − 21 − 10 = 18, so = = 9.The endpoint must be checked in the original, unsimplified quotient to confirm the rate is 9.
Work to write
- f(5) = 0
- f(a) = − 3a − 10
- Rate = , a ≠ 5
- − 3a − 10 = (a − 5)(a + 2)
- Rate = a + 2, a ≠ 5
- a + 2 = 9, so a = 7
- Check: = 9
(a) Rate = a + 2, for a ≠ 5. (b) a = 7.
This asks for the rate expression in b, using a fixed starting input 6. Find the average rate of f(x) = + 5 from 6 to b.
- f(6) = + 5 = 36 + 5 = 41; f(b) = + 5.Evaluate the fixed endpoint and substitute the letter at the other endpoint.
- f(b) − f(6) = ( + 5) − 41 = − 36.Subtract the whole starting output; the constants combine: 5 − 41 = −36.
- − 36 = − = (b − 6)(b + 6).Multiplying these two factors gives + 6b − 6b − 36; the middle terms cancel.
- = b + 6, with b ≠ 6.The input change is b − 6, and that nonzero factor multiplies the whole numerator.
This asks for a rate expression rather than one rate number. Find the average rate of f(x) = 3 − 5 on [2, b], with b > 2.
- f(2) = 3(2 − 5 = 3(4) − 5 = 7; f(b) = 3 − 5.Evaluate the fixed input 2 and then substitute the endpoint b.
- f(b) − f(2) = (3 − 5) − 7 = 3 − 12.Subtract the whole starting output; −5 − 7 = −12.
- 3 − 12 = 3( − 4).Both terms contain a factor of 3.
- − 4 = (b − 2)(b + 2).Multiplying back gives + 2b − 2b − 4 = − 4.
- = 3(b + 2) = 3b + 6, with b ≠ 2.The input difference b − 2 is a nonzero factor of the entire top.
- 3b + 6, for b ≠ 2. The stated interval [2, b] uses b > 2
- for b < 2 use [b, 2].
Let f(x) = (x − 1 − 3, which expands to f(x) = − 2x − 2. (a) Write the average rate of change of f between x = 5 and x = a as a simplified expression in a, with a ≠ 5. (b) The average rate of change on [5, a] is 10. Find a.
- f(5) = − 2(5) − 2 = 25 − 10 − 2 = 13.The fixed numerical endpoint is evaluated first, so one output is a plain number.
- f(a) = − 2a − 2.Substituting the letter a for x gives the other output as an expression.
- Rate = = = , with a ≠ 5.The average rate is the change in output over the matching change in input, taken in the same order. a ≠ 5 keeps the denominator nonzero.
- Factor − 2a − 15. Look for two numbers with product −15 and sum −2. These are −5 and 3, so − 2a − 15 = (a − 5)(a + 3). Check: (a − 5)(a + 3) = + 3a − 5a − 15 = − 2a − 15.This is the sum-and-product puzzle for a monic quadratic. Multiplying back confirms the factorization is correct.
- = a + 3, for a ≠ 5.(a − 5) multiplies the whole numerator and matches the denominator, so it cancels. The restriction a ≠ 5 from the original quotient still applies.
- Set a + 3 = 10, so a = 7. Since 7 > 5, the interval is [5, 7].The given rate equals the simplified expression. The value a = 7 is allowed because it is not 5.
Work to write
- f(5) = 13
- f(a) = − 2a − 2
- , a ≠ 5
- − 2a − 15 = (a − 5)(a + 3)
- rate = a + 3, a ≠ 5
- a + 3 = 10 ⇒ a = 7
- check: = 10
(a) The rate is a + 3, for a ≠ 5. (b) a = 7.
Let f(x) = − 6x + 4, which can also be written f(x) = (x − 3 − 5. (a) Write the average rate of change of f between the inputs 5 and a, where a ≠ 5, as a simplified expression in a. (b) The average rate of change of f between 5 and a equals 3. Find a and state the interval, written with the smaller endpoint first.
- f(5) = − 6(5) + 4 = 25 − 30 + 4 = −1The fixed endpoint is a number, so its output can be computed directly.
- f(a) = − 6a + 4Substituting the letter a for x gives the output at the other endpoint.
- rate = = = Average rate of change is the change in output divided by the matching change in input, with the inputs in the same order as the outputs.
- − 6a + 5 = (a − 1)(a − 5). Check: (a − 1)(a − 5) = − 5a − a + 5 = − 6a + 5Factoring shows whether the numerator contains the factor (a − 5). Multiplying back confirms the factoring.
- rate = = a − 1, for a ≠ 5(a − 5) multiplies the whole numerator, so it cancels. The restriction a ≠ 5 stays because the original quotient is undefined at a = 5.
- a − 1 = 3, so a = 4Setting the simplified rate equal to the given value gives a linear equation in a.
- a = 4 satisfies a ≠ 5. Since 4 < 5, the sorted interval is [4, 5].The solution must satisfy the original restriction. An interval is written with the smaller endpoint first.
Work to write
- f(5) = −1
- f(a) = − 6a + 4
- − 6a + 5 = (a − 1)(a − 5)
- rate = a − 1, a ≠ 5
- a − 1 = 3 so a = 4
- interval [4, 5]
- check: = 3
(a) The average rate of change is a − 1, with a ≠ 5. (b) a = 4, and the interval is [4, 5].
This asks for an endpoint giving a specified average rate. Let g(x) = . Starting at 3, find b > 3 so the average rate on [3, b] is −1.
- Require b ≠ 0 for g(b), and b ≠ 3 for the input change. g(3) = = 4; g(b) = .Both the function output and the rate quotient need nonzero bottoms.
- g(b) − g(3) = − 4 = − = .Write the whole number 4 over bottom b by multiplying it by = 1.
- 12 − 4b = −4(b − 3).Multiplying −4 through the parentheses gives −4b + 12, the same numerator.
- The rate is ÷ (b − 3) = · = .Dividing by b − 3 means multiplying by its reciprocal; the factor cancels only because b ≠ 3.
- Set = −1, then multiply both sides by b: −4 = −b.This finds the input that gives rate −1; multiplying by b is allowed because b ≠ 0.
- Multiply both sides by −1: b = 4.The same multiplication preserves the equality and makes b positive.
- 4 > 3, 4 ≠ 0, and 4 ≠ 3.The candidate satisfies the requested interval and both original restrictions.
- If the problem gives a rate and asks for an endpoint, build the rate expression first and solve second.
- Multiply proposed factors back out; this checks the numerator before cancellation.
- Keep the original excluded input beside every final expression.
- Write interval endpoints in increasing order. Reversing both subtractions preserves the rate, but reversing only one changes its sign.