Quarry School

When an endpoint is a letter, the answer is an expression

Explain it like I am five

Sometimes one end of the interval is a letter, like [0, a] or [5, a]. You follow exactly the same steps, but the letter stays a letter, so the answer is an expression such as a + 7 instead of a single number. That expression is a reusable shortcut: put in any allowed endpoint for a and it gives the average rate of change, with no new work. Think of a taxi fare formula: once you have it, you can price different trip lengths. Here you are building the rate formula rather than the fare formula. Factoring means rewriting a sum as multiplication; that can reveal a whole factor to cancel.

−4−22468−881624324048566472(5, 27)(7, 55)
At a = 7, the dashed ruler through the two curve points has slope 14 = a + 7; it is not part of f.
Reminder
  • Sum-and-product factoring. (a + p)(a + q) = a2 + (p + q)a + pq. For a2 + 2a − 35, choose p = 7 and q = −5.
  • Difference of squares. b2 − 4 = (b − 2)(b + 2), since the +2b and −2b terms cancel when multiplied out.
  • Solving a one-step equation. In b + 3 = 11, subtract 3 from both sides to get b = 8, then substitute 8 back into the equation.
  • Canceling a common factor. a(a+3)a = a + 3 requires a ≠ 0. Canceling reverses multiplication, not addition.
Why it works. A letter stands for a number you have not picked, so arithmetic still applies. For the harder example, (a + 7)(a − 5) multiplies out to a2 − 5a + 7a − 35 = a2 + 2a − 35. This directly proves the factorization. The denominator a − 5 is then a factor of the whole numerator, so it cancels when a ≠ 5. At a = 5 the original rate still divides by zero. The matching-factor method works for these polynomial examples; other formulas can require fraction arithmetic or a different simplification.
RuleFor a fixed input 5 and an endpoint a, rate = f(a)−f(5)a−5, with a ≠ 5 and both outputs defined. On [5, a], a > 5; if a < 5, use the sorted interval [a, 5]. Factor a polynomial numerator before canceling a matching whole factor.
The same idea, five ways
Say it

Say 'the endpoint is a number I have not chosen yet'.

Write it

The average rate can be an expression in the endpoint letter; choosing an endpoint then gives a numerical rate.

In math
  • g(a)−g(0)a, a ≠ 0
  • f(a)−f(5)a−5, a ≠ 5
  • [5, a] for a > 5; [a, 5] for a < 5
Like

A reusable taxi price formula works for many trip lengths; a reusable rate formula works for many endpoints.

See it
input aoutput rate on [5, a]613714815916↓ evaluate: input given, read the output below it
The column under a = 7 gives rate 14, and each rate is its input a plus 7.
The same idea, other ways
Numbers before a formula

For f(x) = x2 + 2x − 8, start at 5. Read the drawn columns as input endpoint above average rate. At a = 7, the column gives 14 because 55−277−5 = 14. Each column follows the expression a + 7; the worked algebra below explains why the same shortcut serves every allowed endpoint.

input aoutput rate on [5, a]613714815916↓ evaluate: input given, read the output below it
The column under a = 7 gives rate 14, and each rate is its input a plus 7.
A reusable price card

A taxi price card accepts a chosen trip length. In the same way, the rate expression a + 7 accepts a chosen endpoint. Choosing a = 6 gives 13; choosing a = 8 gives 15. The endpoint letter names a number, rather than an instruction to solve yet.

a = 8a + 715inputoutput
Once built, the rate expression can be evaluated for a chosen endpoint.
Factoring runs multiplication backward

The product (a + 7)(a − 5) gives a2 + 2a − 35 when multiplied out. This makes the matching whole factor a − 5 visible. Canceling then means dividing that factor by itself, which gives 1 when it is nonzero.

a2 + 2a − 35
= (a + 7)(a − 5)
a ≠ 5
A matching multiplier can cancel; a piece of a sum cannot.
.1A letter becomes a number when you choose it

A letter endpoint allows many numerical intervals to be described at once. A rate table can show the pattern before you rebuild it algebraically.

  • For f(x) = x2 + 2x − 8 starting at 5, rate = a + 7.
  • x, t, a, and b are names; their role is determined by the formula and the question.
input aoutput rate on [5, a]613714815916↓ evaluate: input given, read the output below it
The column under a = 7 gives rate 14, and each rate is its input a plus 7.
Worked exampleA letter names an endpoint number

This asks for one numerical average before rebuilding all endpoints at once. Take a = 7 in f(x) = x2 + 2x − 8 on [5, a].

input aoutput rate on [5, a]613714815916↓ evaluate: input given, read the output below it
The column under a = 7 gives rate 14, and each rate is its input a plus 7.
  1. The endpoint interval becomes [5, 7], with f(5) = 25 + 10 − 8 = 27 and f(7) = 49 + 14 − 8 = 55.Choosing a = 7 gives a numerical value to the endpoint letter.
  2. 55−277−5 = 282 = 14.The ordinary endpoint formula still applies; the rate table highlights this result under input 7.
Answer
14.
Check The reusable answer a + 7 gives 7 + 7 = 14, agreeing with the direct calculation.
.2A three-term numerator needs a factoring puzzle

After evaluating and subtracting, a2 + 2a − 35 needs two factors. Find numbers that multiply to −35 and add to 2. Check the product before canceling.

  • 7 · (−5) = −35 and 7 + (−5) = 2.
  • (a + 7)(a − 5) = a2 + 2a − 35.
  • The original rate excludes a = 5.
−4−22468−881624324048566472(5, 27)(7, 55)
At a = 7, the dashed ruler through the two curve points has slope 14 = a + 7; it is not part of f.
Worked exampleAverage rate of change on [5, a] for a quadratic, then solving for a

Let f(x) = x2 − 4x + 1, which can also be written f(x) = (x − 2)2 − 3. Consider the interval [5, a], where a > 5.
(1) Write the average rate of change of f on [5, a] as a simplified expression in a.
(2) Find the value of a for which the average rate of change on [5, a] equals 9.

−2246810−44812162024283236(5, 6)(8, 33)
The parabola f(x) = (x − 2)2 − 3 with the points (5, 6) and (8, 33) marked. The secant line through these points has slope 9.
  1. Evaluate the fixed endpoint: f(5) = 52 − 4(5) + 1 = 25 − 20 + 1 = 6.The input 5 is a number, so its output is a number. It is one of the two outputs in the difference quotient.
  2. Substitute the letter: f(a) = a2 − 4a + 1.The other endpoint is the letter a. Replacing x with a gives the second output as an expression.
  3. Write the quotient: rate = f(a)−f(5)a−5 = (a2−4a+1)−6a−5 = a2−4a−5a−5, with a ≠ 5.Average rate of change is the change in output over the change in input. Both differences take the same order: a first, then 5. The denominator cannot be zero, so a ≠ 5. This also follows from the condition a > 5.
  4. Factor the numerator: a2 − 4a − 5 = (a − 5)(a + 1). Check by multiplying back: (a − 5)(a + 1) = a2 + a − 5a − 5 = a2 − 4a − 5. ✓Two numbers that multiply to −5 and add to −4 are −5 and +1. Multiplying back confirms the factorization before anything is canceled.
  5. Cancel the common factor: (a−5)(a+1)a−5 = a + 1, for a ≠ 5.The factor (a − 5) multiplies the whole numerator, so it may be canceled. The restriction a ≠ 5 comes from the original quotient and stays in place.
  6. Set the rate equal to 9 and solve: a + 1 = 9, so a = 8.The simplified expression gives the rate for every allowed a. Setting it equal to the given rate leaves a linear equation.
  7. Check the endpoint. The value a = 8 satisfies a > 5 and a ≠ 5. In the original quotient, f(8) = 64 − 32 + 1 = 33, and 33−68−5 = 273 = 9. ✓Any solution must be checked against the original restrictions and the original unsimplified quotient, not only the simplified expression.
Answer
(1) The average rate of change on [5, a] is a + 1, for a ≠ 5 (here a > 5). (2) a = 8, so the interval is [5, 8].
Check f(5) = 6 and f(8) = 33. The rate is 33−68−5 = 273 = 9. The expression a + 1 at a = 8 also gives 9, so the two agree.

Work to write

  1. f(5) = 6
  2. f(a) = a2 − 4a + 1
  3. rate = a2−4a−5a−5, a ≠ 5
  4. a2 − 4a − 5 = (a − 5)(a + 1)
  5. rate = a + 1, a ≠ 5
  6. a + 1 = 9 ⇒ a = 8
  7. Check: 33−68−5 = 9 ✓

(1) The average rate of change on [5, a] is a + 1, for a ≠ 5 (here a > 5). (2) a = 8, so the interval is [5, 8].

.3Working backward from a given rate

Evaluate means an input is given and you find the output. Solve means a target is given and you find the input that produces it. First build the rate expression, then solve for the endpoint that gives the target rate.

  • A target rate produces an equation for the endpoint.
  • Check the candidate in the original quotient, not only the shortened expression.
  • A canceled denominator still leaves an excluded input.
b + 311=do the same thing to both sides
The average rate is known, so solve for the endpoint that balances this equation.
Worked exampleA given rate of change that leads to an endpoint left of 5

Let f(x) = x2 + 2x − 6, which can also be written f(x) = (x + 1)2 − 7. Consider the interval whose endpoints are 5 and a, where a ≠ 5.
(1) Write the average rate of change of f between 5 and a as a simplified expression in a.
(2) Find the value of a for which this average rate of change equals 4. Write the interval in sorted order and check your answer in the original quotient.

−6−4−2246−8−448121620242832(5, 29)(−3, −3)
The parabola f(x) = (x + 1)2 − 7 with the points (−3, −3) and (5, 29). The secant line through them has slope 4, the given average rate of change.
  1. f(5) = 52 + 2(5) − 6 = 25 + 10 − 6 = 29The fixed numerical endpoint is evaluated first, so one output is a plain number.
  2. f(a) = a2 + 2a − 6Substituting the letter a for x gives the other output as an expression. It is defined for every real a.
  3. rate = f(a)−f(5)a−5 = (a2+2a−6)−29a−5 = a2+2a−35a−5, with a ≠ 5Average rate of change is the change in output over the matching change in input. Both differences take the same order, a first and 5 second. The denominator cannot be zero, so a ≠ 5.
  4. Factor: a2 + 2a − 35 = (a − 5)(a + 7). Multiply back to verify: (a − 5)(a + 7) = a2 + 7a − 5a − 35 = a2 + 2a − 35 ✓We need two numbers with product −35 and sum 2. These are 7 and −5. Multiplying back confirms the factoring.
  5. rate = (a−5)(a+7)a−5 = a + 7, for a ≠ 5(a − 5) multiplies the whole numerator, so it can be canceled with the denominator. The restriction a ≠ 5 comes from the original quotient and is kept.
  6. Set a + 7 = 4, so a = −3.The rate is given as 4, so set the simplified expression equal to 4 and solve. The result a = −3 satisfies a ≠ 5.
  7. Since −3 < 5, the sorted interval is [−3, 5].When the letter endpoint is less than 5, the interval is written from smaller to larger. The quotient f(a)−f(5)a−5 gives the same value in either order.
  8. Check in the original quotient: f(−3) = 9 − 6 − 6 = −3, so f(−3)−f(5)−3−5 = −3−29−8 = −32−8 = 4 ✓Checking the endpoint in the unsimplified quotient confirms that the cancellation and the solving are correct.
Answer
(1) The average rate of change is a + 7, for a ≠ 5. (2) a = −3, so the interval is [−3, 5].
Check f(5) = 29 and f(−3) = −3. Over [−3, 5] the output rises by 29 − (−3) = 32 while the input rises by 5 − (−3) = 8. The rate is 328 = 4, which matches the given rate. The formula agrees: a + 7 = −3 + 7 = 4.

Work to write

  1. f(5) = 29
  2. rate = a2+2a−6−29a−5 = a2+2a−35a−5, a ≠ 5
  3. a2 + 2a − 35 = (a − 5)(a + 7)
  4. rate = a + 7, a ≠ 5
  5. a + 7 = 4 ⇒ a = −3
  6. interval [−3, 5]
  7. check: −3−29−3−5 = −32−8 = 4

(1) The average rate of change is a + 7, for a ≠ 5. (2) a = −3, so the interval is [−3, 5].

.4Working backward when the rate contains a fraction

First combine the function outputs into one fraction. Dividing by the input difference can cancel a whole factor, leaving a rate equation you solve by doing the same multiplication to both sides.

  • For g(x) = 12x starting at 3, rate = −4b, with b ≠ 0 and b ≠ 3.
  • Target rate −1 gives b = 4.
−4 ÷ b−1=do the same thing to both sides
First build the rate expression; then find the endpoint that gives the target.
Worked exampleRung 7: work backward with a fraction

This asks for an endpoint giving a specified average rate. Let g(x) = 12x. Starting at 3, find b > 3 so the average rate on [3, b] is −1.

−4 ÷ b−1=do the same thing to both sides
First build the rate expression; then find the endpoint that gives the target.
  1. Require b ≠ 0 for g(b), and b ≠ 3 for the input change. g(3) = 123 = 4; g(b) = 12b.Both the function output and the rate quotient need nonzero bottoms.
  2. g(b) − g(3) = 12b − 4 = 12b − 4bb = 12−4bb.Write the whole number 4 over bottom b by multiplying it by bb = 1.
  3. 12 − 4b = −4(b − 3).Multiplying −4 through the parentheses gives −4b + 12, the same numerator.
  4. The rate is −4(b−3)b ÷ (b − 3) = −4(b−3)b · 1b−3 = −4b.Dividing by b − 3 means multiplying by its reciprocal; the factor cancels only because b ≠ 3.
  5. Set −4b = −1, then multiply both sides by b: −4 = −b.This finds the input that gives rate −1; multiplying by b is allowed because b ≠ 0.
  6. Multiply both sides by −1: b = 4.The same multiplication preserves the equality and makes b positive.
  7. 4 > 3, 4 ≠ 0, and 4 ≠ 3.The candidate satisfies the requested interval and both original restrictions.
Answer
b = 4.
Check In the original rate, g(4) = 3 and g(3) = 4, so 3−44−3 = −11 = −1.
Strategy: step by step
  1. Evaluate the fixed numerical endpoint.
  2. Substitute the endpoint letter to write the other output.
  3. Subtract the outputs and write the matching input difference.
  4. For a polynomial, factor the numerator and verify by multiplying back.
  5. Cancel only a matching factor multiplying the whole numerator, preserving the original restrictions.
  6. If the rate is given, set the simplified rate expression equal to that number, solve, and check the endpoint in the original quotient.
Strategy
A letter endpoint, forward or backward
1
Does the fixed endpoint equal 0?
YesCompute f(0); the input difference is the endpoint letter.
NoSubtract the actual fixed input in the denominator.
↓
2
Is the numerator a polynomial with a common factor?
YesWrite each term as that common factor times something and factor it out.
NoLook for a difference of squares or the sum-and-product pattern; for fractions use a common bottom.
↓
3
Is the rate given and the endpoint requested?
YesSet the simplified expression equal to the given rate, solve, and check the original restrictions.
NoLeave the result as an expression with restrictions.
↓
4
Does the proposed endpoint make any original denominator 0?
YesReject it even if it satisfies the simplified expression.
NoCheck it in the original rate formula.
  1. Build the endpoint quotient before simplifying.
  2. Record all excluded inputs from function bottoms and the input difference.
  3. Use common factors, a difference of squares, or the sum-and-product factor puzzle when applicable.
  4. If requested, solve the rate equation and check the candidate in the original quotient.
Worked exampleAverage rate of change from 5 to a letter endpoint, then solving for the endpoint

Let f(x) = x2 − 2x − 2. (a) Write the average rate of change of f between the inputs 5 and a, where a ≠ 5, as a simplified expression in a. (b) The average rate of change of f between 5 and a equals 7. Find a and state the interval.

−2246−4−22468101214(4, 6)(5, 13)
The graph of f(x) = (x − 1)2 − 3 = x2 − 2x − 2, marking the points (4, 6) and (5, 13). The secant line through them has slope 7, which is the average rate of change on [4, 5].
  1. f(5) = 52 − 2(5) − 2 = 25 − 10 − 2 = 13.The fixed numerical endpoint gives a number, so evaluate it first.
  2. f(a) = a2 − 2a − 2.Replace every x with the endpoint letter a to get the other output.
  3. rate = f(a)−f(5)a−5 = (a2−2a−2)−13a−5 = a2−2a−15a−5, with a ≠ 5.The average rate is the change in output over the matching change in input, in the same order. a = 5 would make the denominator zero.
  4. a2 − 2a − 15 = (a − 5)(a + 3). Check: (a − 5)(a + 3) = a2 + 3a − 5a − 15 = a2 − 2a − 15.Factor the polynomial numerator so that any factor matching the denominator becomes visible. Multiplying back confirms the factoring.
  5. rate = (a−5)(a+3)a−5 = a + 3, for a ≠ 5.(a − 5) multiplies the whole numerator and equals the denominator, so it cancels. The restriction a ≠ 5 from the original quotient still holds.
  6. Set a + 3 = 7, so a = 4.The given rate equals the simplified expression, so solve that equation for the endpoint.
  7. Check a = 4 in the original quotient: f(4) = 16 − 8 − 2 = 6, and 6−134−5 = −7−1 = 7. Since 4 < 5, the sorted interval is [4, 5].The endpoint must satisfy a ≠ 5 and give the stated rate in the unsimplified quotient. An interval is written with its smaller endpoint first.
Answer
(a) The rate is a + 3, for a ≠ 5. (b) a = 4, and the interval is [4, 5].
Check Use a = 6 in part (a): f(6) = 36 − 12 − 2 = 22, and 22−136−5 = 9. The formula gives 6 + 3 = 9, so the expression agrees. For part (b), the points (4, 6) and (5, 13) give a slope of 13−65−4 = 7.

Work to write

  1. f(5) = 13
  2. f(a) = a2 − 2a − 2
  3. a2−2a−15a−5, a ≠ 5
  4. a2 − 2a − 15 = (a − 5)(a + 3)
  5. rate = a + 3, a ≠ 5
  6. a + 3 = 7 ⇒ a = 4
  7. Check: 6−134−5 = 7; interval [4, 5]

(a) The rate is a + 3, for a ≠ 5. (b) a = 4, and the interval is [4, 5].

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard. Press Try it first on any rung to hide its steps and use them as hints.
Rung 1Rung 1: a linear formula needs no factoring puzzle

This asks for the average rate from a fixed input to any different input b. Find it for f(x) = 4x + 9, starting at −2.

−2246−44812162024283236run 1rise 4(−2, 1)(6, 33)
A straight line adds 4 output units per input unit.
  1. f(−2) = 4(−2) + 9 = −8 + 9 = 1; f(b) = 4b + 9.The first output is numerical; the second keeps the endpoint letter.
  2. Output change: f(b) − f(−2) = (4b + 9) − 1 = 4b + 8.Subtract the entire starting output.
  3. Input change: b − (−2) = b + 2.The input change follows the same endpoint order.
  4. 4b + 8 = 4(b + 2), so 4(b+2)b+2 = 4, with b ≠ −2.The factor b + 2 multiplies the whole top. The original bottom excludes b = −2.
Answer
4, for b ≠ −2. Use [−2, b] if b > −2, and [b, −2] if b < −2.
Check Choose b = 6: f(6) = 33 and 33−16−(−2) = 328 = 4.
Rung 2Average rate of change on [5, a] when f(5) = 0

Let f(x) = x2 − 3x − 10. (a) Write the average rate of change of f from x = 5 to x = a, where a ≠ 5, as a simplified expression in a. (b) The average rate of change on [5, a] is 9. Find a.

−4−22468−12−9−6−3369121518(5, 0)(7, 18)
The parabola f(x) = x2 − 3x − 10 crosses the x-axis at (5, 0) and passes through (7, 18). The segment joining these two points has slope 9, which is the average rate of change on [5, 7].
  1. f(5) = 52 − 3(5) − 10 = 25 − 15 − 10 = 0.The fixed numerical endpoint is evaluated first. Its output is 0, so subtracting it will not change the numerator.
  2. f(a) = a2 − 3a − 10.Replacing x with the endpoint letter a gives the other output.
  3. Rate = f(a)−f(5)a−5 = (a2−3a−10)−0a−5 = a2−3a−10a−5, with a ≠ 5.Average rate of change is the change in output divided by the matching change in input, taken in the same order. The denominator cannot be 0.
  4. Factor the numerator: a2 − 3a − 10 = (a − 5)(a + 2). Check by multiplying back: (a − 5)(a + 2) = a2 + 2a − 5a − 10 = a2 − 3a − 10.We need two numbers with product −10 and sum −3. Those are −5 and 2. Multiplying back confirms the factoring.
  5. Rate = (a−5)(a+2)a−5 = a + 2, for a ≠ 5.(a − 5) multiplies the whole numerator and matches the denominator, so it cancels. The restriction a ≠ 5 from the original quotient still applies.
  6. Set a + 2 = 9, so a = 7. Since 7 > 5, the interval is [5, 7].The given rate equals the simplified expression. The solution a = 7 is not 5, so it is allowed, and it gives the sorted interval [5, a].
  7. Check in the original quotient: f(7) = 49 − 21 − 10 = 18, so 18−07−5 = 182 = 9.The endpoint must be checked in the original, unsimplified quotient to confirm the rate is 9.
Answer
(a) Rate = a + 2, for a ≠ 5. (b) a = 7.
Check Test a = 6 in part (a): f(6) = 36 − 18 − 10 = 8, so 8−06−5 = 8, and a + 2 = 8. For part (b), the secant line from (5, 0) to (7, 18) has slope 182 = 9.

Work to write

  1. f(5) = 0
  2. f(a) = a2 − 3a − 10
  3. Rate = a2−3a−10a−5, a ≠ 5
  4. a2 − 3a − 10 = (a − 5)(a + 2)
  5. Rate = a + 2, a ≠ 5
  6. a + 2 = 9, so a = 7
  7. Check: 18−07−5 = 9

(a) Rate = a + 2, for a ≠ 5. (b) a = 7.

Rung 3Rung 3: a difference of squares

This asks for the rate expression in b, using a fixed starting input 6. Find the average rate of f(x) = x2 + 5 from 6 to b.

2468102030405060708090100start 6b = 9
With b = 9, the dashed ruler from (6, 41) to (9, 86) has slope 15 = 9 + 6.
b2 + 5 − 41 = b2 − 36
= (b − 6)(b + 6)
rate = b + 6
Factor the whole numerator before canceling b − 6.
2468102030405060708090100start 6b = 9
With b = 9, the dashed ruler from (6, 41) to (9, 86) has slope 15 = 9 + 6.
  1. f(6) = 62 + 5 = 36 + 5 = 41; f(b) = b2 + 5.Evaluate the fixed endpoint and substitute the letter at the other endpoint.
  2. f(b) − f(6) = (b2 + 5) − 41 = b2 − 36.Subtract the whole starting output; the constants combine: 5 − 41 = −36.
  3. b2 − 36 = b2 − 62 = (b − 6)(b + 6).Multiplying these two factors gives b2 + 6b − 6b − 36; the middle terms cancel.
  4. (b−6)(b+6)b−6 = b + 6, with b ≠ 6.The input change is b − 6, and that nonzero factor multiplies the whole numerator.
Answer
b + 6, for b ≠ 6. Sort the interval endpoints according to whether b is greater or less than 6.
Check Choose b = 9: f(9) = 86, so 86−419−6 = 453 = 15 = 9 + 6.
Rung 4Rung 4: a coefficient and a difference of squares

This asks for a rate expression rather than one rate number. Find the average rate of f(x) = 3x2 − 5 on [2, b], with b > 2.

3b2 − 12
= 3(b − 2)(b + 2)
rate = 3b + 6
The matching factor b − 2 cancels only when b ≠ 2.
  1. f(2) = 3(2)2 − 5 = 3(4) − 5 = 7; f(b) = 3b2 − 5.Evaluate the fixed input 2 and then substitute the endpoint b.
  2. f(b) − f(2) = (3b2 − 5) − 7 = 3b2 − 12.Subtract the whole starting output; −5 − 7 = −12.
  3. 3b2 − 12 = 3(b2 − 4).Both terms contain a factor of 3.
  4. b2 − 4 = (b − 2)(b + 2).Multiplying back gives b2 + 2b − 2b − 4 = b2 − 4.
  5. 3(b−2)(b+2)b−2 = 3(b + 2) = 3b + 6, with b ≠ 2.The input difference b − 2 is a nonzero factor of the entire top.
Answer
  • 3b + 6, for b ≠ 2. The stated interval [2, b] uses b > 2
  • for b < 2 use [b, 2].
Check The original check b = 3 gives f(3) = 22 and 22−73−2 = 15 = 3(3) + 6. With b = 5, f(5) = 70 and 70−75−2 = 633 = 21.
Rung 5Average rate on [5, a] for a shifted parabola, then find a

Let f(x) = (x − 1)2 − 3, which expands to f(x) = x2 − 2x − 2. (a) Write the average rate of change of f between x = 5 and x = a as a simplified expression in a, with a ≠ 5. (b) The average rate of change on [5, a] is 10. Find a.

−22468−44812162024283236(5, 13)(7, 33)
Graph of f(x) = (x − 1)2 − 3 with the endpoints (5, 13) and (7, 33). The secant line through these two points has slope 10.
  1. f(5) = 52 − 2(5) − 2 = 25 − 10 − 2 = 13.The fixed numerical endpoint is evaluated first, so one output is a plain number.
  2. f(a) = a2 − 2a − 2.Substituting the letter a for x gives the other output as an expression.
  3. Rate = f(a)−f(5)a−5 = (a2−2a−2)−13a−5 = a2−2a−15a−5, with a ≠ 5.The average rate is the change in output over the matching change in input, taken in the same order. a ≠ 5 keeps the denominator nonzero.
  4. Factor a2 − 2a − 15. Look for two numbers with product −15 and sum −2. These are −5 and 3, so a2 − 2a − 15 = (a − 5)(a + 3). Check: (a − 5)(a + 3) = a2 + 3a − 5a − 15 = a2 − 2a − 15.This is the sum-and-product puzzle for a monic quadratic. Multiplying back confirms the factorization is correct.
  5. (a−5)(a+3)a−5 = a + 3, for a ≠ 5.(a − 5) multiplies the whole numerator and matches the denominator, so it cancels. The restriction a ≠ 5 from the original quotient still applies.
  6. Set a + 3 = 10, so a = 7. Since 7 > 5, the interval is [5, 7].The given rate equals the simplified expression. The value a = 7 is allowed because it is not 5.
Answer
(a) The rate is a + 3, for a ≠ 5. (b) a = 7.
Check In the original quotient: f(7) = 49 − 14 − 2 = 33, and f(5) = 13. Then 33−137−5 = 202 = 10, which matches the given rate.

Work to write

  1. f(5) = 13
  2. f(a) = a2 − 2a − 2
  3. a2−2a−15a−5, a ≠ 5
  4. a2 − 2a − 15 = (a − 5)(a + 3)
  5. rate = a + 3, a ≠ 5
  6. a + 3 = 10 ⇒ a = 7
  7. check: 33−137−5 = 10

(a) The rate is a + 3, for a ≠ 5. (b) a = 7.

Rung 6Finding an unknown endpoint from a given average rate of change

Let f(x) = x2 − 6x + 4, which can also be written f(x) = (x − 3)2 − 5. (a) Write the average rate of change of f between the inputs 5 and a, where a ≠ 5, as a simplified expression in a. (b) The average rate of change of f between 5 and a equals 3. Find a and state the interval, written with the smaller endpoint first.

2468−6−4−2246(4, −4)(5, −1)
Graph of f(x) = (x − 3)2 − 5 with the points (4, −4) and (5, −1). The secant line through these points has slope 3.
  1. f(5) = 52 − 6(5) + 4 = 25 − 30 + 4 = −1The fixed endpoint is a number, so its output can be computed directly.
  2. f(a) = a2 − 6a + 4Substituting the letter a for x gives the output at the other endpoint.
  3. rate = f(a)−f(5)a−5 = (a2−6a+4)−(−1)a−5 = a2−6a+5a−5Average rate of change is the change in output divided by the matching change in input, with the inputs in the same order as the outputs.
  4. a2 − 6a + 5 = (a − 1)(a − 5). Check: (a − 1)(a − 5) = a2 − 5a − a + 5 = a2 − 6a + 5Factoring shows whether the numerator contains the factor (a − 5). Multiplying back confirms the factoring.
  5. rate = (a−1)(a−5)a−5 = a − 1, for a ≠ 5(a − 5) multiplies the whole numerator, so it cancels. The restriction a ≠ 5 stays because the original quotient is undefined at a = 5.
  6. a − 1 = 3, so a = 4Setting the simplified rate equal to the given value gives a linear equation in a.
  7. a = 4 satisfies a ≠ 5. Since 4 < 5, the sorted interval is [4, 5].The solution must satisfy the original restriction. An interval is written with the smaller endpoint first.
Answer
(a) The average rate of change is a − 1, with a ≠ 5. (b) a = 4, and the interval is [4, 5].
Check f(4) = 16 − 24 + 4 = −4 and f(5) = −1. In the original quotient, f(4)−f(5)4−5 = −4−(−1)−1 = −3−1 = 3, which matches the given rate.

Work to write

  1. f(5) = −1
  2. f(a) = a2 − 6a + 4
  3. a2−6a+5a−5
  4. a2 − 6a + 5 = (a − 1)(a − 5)
  5. rate = a − 1, a ≠ 5
  6. a − 1 = 3 so a = 4
  7. interval [4, 5]
  8. check: −4−(−1)4−5 = 3

(a) The average rate of change is a − 1, with a ≠ 5. (b) a = 4, and the interval is [4, 5].

Rung 7Rung 7: work backward with a fraction

This asks for an endpoint giving a specified average rate. Let g(x) = 12x. Starting at 3, find b > 3 so the average rate on [3, b] is −1.

−4 ÷ b−1=do the same thing to both sides
First build the rate expression; then find the endpoint that gives the target.
  1. Require b ≠ 0 for g(b), and b ≠ 3 for the input change. g(3) = 123 = 4; g(b) = 12b.Both the function output and the rate quotient need nonzero bottoms.
  2. g(b) − g(3) = 12b − 4 = 12b − 4bb = 12−4bb.Write the whole number 4 over bottom b by multiplying it by bb = 1.
  3. 12 − 4b = −4(b − 3).Multiplying −4 through the parentheses gives −4b + 12, the same numerator.
  4. The rate is −4(b−3)b ÷ (b − 3) = −4(b−3)b · 1b−3 = −4b.Dividing by b − 3 means multiplying by its reciprocal; the factor cancels only because b ≠ 3.
  5. Set −4b = −1, then multiply both sides by b: −4 = −b.This finds the input that gives rate −1; multiplying by b is allowed because b ≠ 0.
  6. Multiply both sides by −1: b = 4.The same multiplication preserves the equality and makes b positive.
  7. 4 > 3, 4 ≠ 0, and 4 ≠ 3.The candidate satisfies the requested interval and both original restrictions.
Answer
b = 4.
Check In the original rate, g(4) = 3 and g(3) = 4, so 3−44−3 = −11 = −1.
Counterexamples: what it is not, and the tempting wrong moves
✗ Not this: Cancel a from a2 + 2a − 35 against the a in a − 5.
Those a pieces belong to sums. They are not one factor multiplying the whole top and bottom.
✓ Instead: Factor the top as (a + 7)(a − 5), then cancel the whole factor a − 5 for a ≠ 5.
✗ Not this: The simplified expression a + 7 lets a = 5 have rate 12.
The original quotient at a = 5 has input difference 0 and is undefined.
✓ Instead: Keep a ≠ 5 even after the denominator disappears.
✗ Not this: Any expression that is 0 at a = 5 automatically has a visible factor a − 5.
A zero value alone is not a factoring calculation for every kind of function. Here the product must be shown or justified for the particular expression.
✓ Instead: Multiply (a + 7)(a − 5) back out to prove this example's polynomial factorization.
✗ Not this: In every lesson the letter a is always the left endpoint.
Letters name different jobs in different questions. In [5, a] with a > 5, a is the right endpoint.
✓ Instead: Identify the fixed input and the changing endpoint before computing.
Tips and tricks
  • If the problem gives a rate and asks for an endpoint, build the rate expression first and solve second.
  • Multiply proposed factors back out; this checks the numerator before cancellation.
  • Keep the original excluded input beside every final expression.
  • Write interval endpoints in increasing order. Reversing both subtractions preserves the rate, but reversing only one changes its sign.
Trap. Canceling pieces of sums instead of whole multiplied factors, or forgetting the excluded endpoint after cancellation.